Monday, May 25, 2009

Why Grain Free?

No one in my family is gluten-intolerant. We don't have celiac disease or crohns disease. We actually tolerate gluten quite well.

So why go grain free?

Good question.

A question that came up a lot recently from several readers who noted that I was planning grain-free menus recently. Rather than re-writing and re-hashing what has already been written, here's the journey we've been going through . . .

First, I came across this post from Shannon at Nourishing Days on Why Grains are Not Necessary for a Nourishing Diet, followed by her follow-up post.

I was intrigued, especially since I completely related to her statement:

"Grains make me tired, sluggish and foggy. They keep me hungry and increase sugar cravings. Most of all they make it extremely difficult for me to maintain a healthy weight. Insulin and leptin seem to be the key hormones in all of this."

I had been planning on returning to a quasi low-carb/"Eat Fat, Lose Fat" inspired diet once the baby was born, but hadn't ever considered that grains were part of the problem and never considered cutting them out completely. I've always considered myself a moderate, but I admit that both my husband and I do better when eating low-carb. And we both need to lose weight.

I began researching the idea further, which led me to finding Son of Grok's blog - which I thought would be inspiring for my husband - and thus to Mark Sisson's Daily Apple, both of which focus on a paleo/primal-inspired diet, completely grain-free.

And then recently, Nourished Kitchen's Jenny wrote a great synopsis of 10 Reasons to Give Up Grain, and it was basically the nail in the coffin. Seriously, I need to print it out and keep it on my fridge.

For me, grains have just kind of been filler. Meal extenders. A means to bring tastier things to the mouth (like meats, cheeses, and spreads). So it really hasn't been that hard to eliminate them. Instead, we've been eating tons more vegetables and fruits . . . more details to come.

We've been experimenting the last few weeks with grain-free and mostly grain-free menus. And you know what? Not only have we been losing weight (four pounds for me in one week!), but our tummies have been feeling better; symptoms that I thought were "normal" for me (because, hey, I already eat a lot of probiotics and enzyme-rich foods - everything should be well digested!) are noticably gone when I reduce/eliminate my grain (and sugar) intake. And that counts for all of us.

And, after only a week of focusing on eliminating grain, when I did "slip" and eat a cracker, it literally tasted like sawdust and had no flavor. I didn't want a second.

We are not saints. We still occasionally have a cheat meal or special dessert. But not often, and our cravings are diminishing by the second (I ordered a sandwich this weekend, without thinking, and ended up only eating half of the bread and eating the remainder of the sandwich with a fork. Because I wanted to. I didn't want the bread; not because I felt in any way guilty. Frankly, it was better that way.). We're still eating some dairy (true primal eaters cut it out for the most part!) - Lloyd and me more so than T. So far we've had about one meal a week with potatoes (not a grain, but not low-carb!) and we are grilling ears of corn for dinner tonight (a grain, not a vegetable!) but for the most part, we're grain-free. And we're doing great!

Why go grain-free? I think the links and blogs above, along with our restored tummies and lost weight are reason enough!

5 comments:

Lenetta @ Nettacow said...

But they're so taaaaasty! (/whine) Thanks for pulling this together, Sarah. Feel free to interject any bits and pieces as to how it's going - no one can expect any long winded posts from you, but I'm definitely intrigued.

I found it interesting that the one link mentioned leaky gut syndrome, which I read a lot about while researching yeast. So much to think about.

The thing that's keeping me from jumping in with both feet is that grains aren't just a filler for me. I don't like meat all that much. And if you take away my black beans, I'm not sure what I'll do! :>) I'll be extra-interested in your menus as you journey through this. Thanks for sharing it with us!

Michelle @ Find Your Balance said...

It's interesting. Civilization as we know it needed grain to develop, but now here we are and maybe we don't need it at all!

Carol said...

When I was doing South Beach (not quite grain-free, but close) I felt so much better than when I started to go back to grains (for example, fresh eggs and some Canadian bacon in the morning help me get going so much better than a bagel). I'm not ready to make a grain-free committment (though I am curbing them), but I do agree that too many grains can make you feel sluggish and generally unhealthy. Plus, you get can most (if not all) of your fiber/carb needs from fruits and beans I would think! Good luck and I look forward to hearing your thoughts on this way of eating as you venture further into it! :-)

motherhen68 said...

We're grain/sugar free around here (dh & I). I too, used to use grains as a filler. I find so many of the menus on MPM are just full of starch! So much so, I basically stopped reading them.

Veggies are a great filler. We did grill some corn yesterday, but it was the first of the season! I won't eat it again this year.

My biggest vice is ice cream. I've gotten away from it, but when I visit Whole Foods (not often as it's an hour from us), I do eat a small gelatto, cuz it's so darn good!

Good luck with your journey. I've lost 55 lbs in a year and a half and I plan to eat this way for life, so I don't plan to gain it back!

Katie @ Kitchen Stewardship said...

Wow, I'm impressed. My husband DOES have Crohn's, but I don't think he'd take too kindly to another big food change around here. We've just been doing raw milk and soaking grains for a few months, and that might be all he can handle for the year, poor man!

Glad to read up on you and that you're doing well. What beautiful boys you have!